Words do not tell the whole story
Original reflection and activity · Buba Bah
Words help us understand the world. But when they turn into labels, they can stop us getting to know the person in front of us.
Calling someone a migrant tells us something about their journey. It does not tell us their dreams, what they have studied, who they love or what they hope to build.
We can begin with a simple question: what would I want to know about this person if I had time to listen? The glossary also explains the differences between migrant, refugee and asylum-seeker: these terms need care and are not interchangeable.
Pause and reflect
- Have you ever been described with a single word?
- What was missing from that description?
- How can we introduce ourselves while leaving room for our complexity?
Five aspects, one person
Choose a fictional character and describe five aspects of their life: an interest, a relationship, a skill, a wish and an important place. Compare your descriptions: what made you curious?
EXPLORE THE CONCEPTSMigrant, refugee and asylum-seeker: understanding the differences
Words can help us understand a situation. On their own, they cannot tell a person’s whole life story.
1. Migrant: a word that needs context
What it meansThere is no single, universally accepted international legal definition of ‘migrant’. Its meaning can vary between a statistical study, a news report and an everyday conversation.
The reasons for moving can differ and overlap: education, work, family ties, economic hardship or other circumstances. Dividing everyone into those who ‘choose freely’ and those who ‘are forced’ can hide more complex situations.
UNHCR advises against using ‘migrant’ as an indiscriminate label that obscures the specific protection owed to refugees and asylum-seekers.
What we cannot infer
Knowing that someone has moved from one country to another does not automatically tell us why they left, which documents they hold or whether they can return safely.
A fictional example
Someone may leave to study and later become unable to return because of new threats. Their circumstances need to be understood over time, rather than only through the original reason for their journey.
2. Refugee: a condition with specific criteria
What it meansUnder the 1951 Refugee Convention, read together with the 1967 Protocol, a refugee is someone outside their country of nationality who has a well-founded fear of persecution and cannot, or because of that fear will not, seek that country’s protection.
The persecution must relate to at least one of the specified grounds: race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion. The definition also covers, under corresponding conditions, people without a nationality who are outside their former country of habitual residence.
Being a refugee and being formally recognised as one are different: a person is a refugee when they meet the applicable criteria. Formal recognition confirms that condition. It is therefore incorrect to say that someone cannot be a refugee before a decision is made.
What we cannot infer
Coming from a particular country does not, on its own, establish an individual’s circumstances. Equally, working or continuing an education does not show that a need for protection is absent.
A fictional example
Someone says they have been threatened because of their political opinions. That may be relevant, but a short account does not allow us to replace an assessment by the competent authorities.
3. Asylum-seeker: a claim to be examined
What it meansAn asylum-seeker is a person seeking international protection. In the context of the procedure, the term describes someone who has applied and is waiting for a final decision.
An application is a request for protection; it does not predict the outcome of the assessment. Not every asylum-seeker will be recognised as a refugee.
In Italy, international protection includes refugee status and subsidiary protection. The latter concerns people who do not meet the requirements for refugee status but would face a real risk of serious harm if returned. These are different conditions, assessed under the applicable rules.
What we cannot infer
Waiting does not prove that an application will succeed or that it is unfounded. An initial negative decision must also be distinguished from any subsequent appeal stage.
A fictional example
A report says: ‘The person has applied for protection and is waiting for a decision.’ We can describe them as an asylum-seeker. We cannot say that they have already been formally recognised, or predict the decision.
4. What does a photograph tell us?
A photograph may show an arrival, a face or a moment. On its own, it does not tell us:
- why a person left;
- their legal situation;
- what they have experienced;
- their skills, relationships or hopes.
We can observe what an image shows while distinguishing it from the interpretations we add.
We know, we imagine, we need to check
Read this invented sentence:
A 24-year-old person arrived by sea. They have applied for international protection and attend an Italian language course.
| What the text tells us | What we do not know | How we could check |
|---|---|---|
| They have applied for protection | What the outcome will be | We cannot predict it; we can only check the stage of the procedure through reliable information, respecting confidentiality |
| They attend an Italian course | Which other languages they know | Through information the person chooses to share |
Divide a sheet into these three columns and add other examples. Discuss: which judgements might we make without sufficient information?
Do not ask participants to show documents or share personal experiences. The whole activity can use fictional examples.
Am I trying to understand this person, or filling the gaps in what I know with my own assumptions?
Educational card with original website examples and activities. These introductory definitions cannot determine individual cases. The sources document the concepts; the examples and activity are not official materials from the organisations cited.
Sources checked: 5 November 2026